logo
logo
 
 
logo Home  |  Store  |  Products  |  Training Center  |  Customer Center  |  About Us    

Response to Intervention

 Renaissance Tools
 for RTI
 
 Tiered Delivery Model
blue dot  STAR vs. CBMs
blue dot  Panel of Experts
blue dot  Key RTI Reports
blue dot  RTI Videos
 U.S. DOE Accolades
 RTI Is Hard—
 We Can Help
 
 Learn More

STAR Assessments vs. CBMs

The goal of RTI is not to use CBMs—rather, it is to generate high-quality data and use it to guide important educational decisions. Renaissance Learning’s STAR Early Literacy, STAR Reading, and STAR Math generate a broad range of information using less teacher time, providing more thorough and detailed data to guide important instructional decisions.

STAR Assessments Provide More Information in Less Time
Value of an Assessment
*Christensen Associates, 2005

Advantages of CAT/IRT Assessments
The computer-based STAR Assessments incorporate two powerful advantages: computer-adaptive testing (CAT) and item response theory (IRT), allowing them to provide:

  • Time efficiency in quick administration
  • Valid and reliable results for students substantially below (or above) grade-level expectations, and for comparing scores across years
  • Richer data for informing instruction
  • Ready access to data through online databases
  • Multiple functions in a single assessment (screening, progress monitoring, diagnostic use)
Shortcomings of CBMs
  • Psychometric concerns with regard to predictivity (Gersten et al., 2008), growth measurement (Betts, Pickart, & Heistad, 2009; Francis et al., 2008, Christ & Ardoin, 2009), lack of a common scale of measurement, and variation in test administration and scoring, contributing to standard error.
  • Inefficiency and cost of administration, in terms of teacher time and time lost from instruction (Christensen Associates, 2005).
  • Lack of data to drive instruction. CBMs may indicate there is a problem but provide little or no information as to what to do about it (Burns, Dean, & Klar, 2004).
References

  © 2010  Renaissance Learning. All rights reserved.

Questions? Call: (800) 338-4204